Which firewall is best?

General discussion related to Cable Modems, DSL, Wireless, Fiber, Mobile Networks, Wireless ISPs, Satellite, or any other type of high-speed Internet connection, general issues and questions here. Review and discuss ISPs as well (AT&T / SBC, BellSouth, Bright House, CableOne, Charter, Comcast, Covad, Cox, Cablevision / Optimum Online, TMobile, Verizon FIOS, Shaw, Telus, Starlink, etc.)
Post Reply
User avatar
HongKongPolice
Senior Member
Posts: 2147
Joined: Thu Jul 08, 1999 12:00 am
Location: I...... AM.......... CANADIAN!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Which firewall is best?

Post by HongKongPolice »

Ok I know that a linux firewall is the best, but I don't have the time or patience to configure it :(

I used to use Tiny Personal Firewall 2.0 and it was perfect until I switched to XP, then it started blocking file sharing packets even when I tell it not to :rolleyes:

Tried upgrading to TPF 5.5, but the interface was so confusing, and certain ports weren't even blocked.

Using Sygate Firewall 5.5 Pro right now, and it is perfect except for 2 things: CPU usage and Latencies. I turned off all logs, yet CPU usage is almost 90% when for transfering files over LAN, due to the firewall. I turned off it completely, and usage goes back down to ~30% or so. The program also tends to lag things up by 1ms. When I ping my dsl router, I get 1ms with the firewall on, 0ms with it off....

There are SO many firewall progs out there, which one combines Sygate's functionality and security with Tiny Personal Firewall's low CPU usage?

Thanks
Abit KR7A-Raid
Palomino 1.4Ghz @ 1.57Ghz @ default voltage /w DTek Spir@l block 512MB Crucial DDR @ 300Mhz CAS222 ATi OEM Radeon8500 @ 295/275 vmem=3.5v, would of gotten GF3 if they had better filters..... 3Com 905 TX SoundBlaster Live OEM 120gig Western Digital Special Edition (8MB Cache) 20gig Fujitsu 5400rpm (gonna get another WD1200JB for Raid0 soon) LiteOn 24x burner Enermax 350watt PSU (voltage modded) Dell P1110 21" Sony FD Trinitron tube @ 1792x1344 85Hz
qball15j
Senior Member
Posts: 3619
Joined: Mon Nov 26, 2001 9:28 pm

Post by qball15j »

Personally I tent to shy away from running personal firewall’s on the local machine. You mentioned above about Linux, there are a number of distributions out there dedicated to being a firewall/router. I recommend SmoothWall, it’s pretty easy to setup. All you need an old comp 486 up to 400 MHz and two NICs. They have pretty detailed manuals if you need them, check it out. The GUI installation makes it easy. http://www.smoothwall.org If you’re still leaning towards a software firewall, use the one that comes with XP. XP’s firewall only blocks incoming packets like a router but it does the job. If I didn’t have a choice I would run the XP firewall, I’m not the kind of person to use 3rd party software if windows can do it.
User avatar
chpalmer
Advanced Member
Posts: 558
Joined: Sun Oct 13, 2002 3:52 pm
Location: Kitsap co Wa

Post by chpalmer »

Kerios 2.15 is the twin of Tiny's 2.15 I had the same problems with it! Im running Kerio 4.0.13 now Works well. ;)


http://www.kerio.com

http://www.kerio.com/kpf_download.html
Never take any crap off an inanimate object!!

Never send email to this address: spam@euclidian.com. This is a spam trap and everyone sending any email to this address will be blacklisted.
Post Reply